“We have two bodies! I became conscious that I am not my physical body but rather, I am an energy body. The soul, which is my true self, lives and temporarily inhabits my physical body. We live temporarily in and through the physical body here on earth, but we are not the body.”
Context: This insight comes after the experiencer recognizes he is the young man lying on the ground and re-experiences the accident, receiving what he calls 'a very great and important insight.'
Review note: The passage explicitly frames the physical body as a temporary vessel inhabited by the soul/true self, directly matching the claim's vehicle/garment language; I agree with the prior verdict.
Read the full account“Like the shell of a crab is an extension of the crab itself, our body is also but a shell, and when it is not needed it will fall away.”
Context: This statement appears in the experiencer's reflective conclusion after describing her NDE, summarizing her understanding that the body is a temporary shell distinct from the true self.
Review note: The passage contains an explicit, direct vehicle/garment-type metaphor ('our body is also but a shell') describing the body as a temporary structure the self uses but is not identical to, perfectly matching the inclusion criteria; I agree with the prior verdict.
Read the full account“I had put on that outfit to experiment. I had been on earth for a certain purpose, but had forgotten about it.”
Context: The experiencer realizes she had no body and no gender, and reflects that her earthly identity was something she had temporarily 'put on' for a purpose.
Review note: The passage explicitly uses garment/clothing metaphor ('put on that outfit') to describe the body as something the self dons temporarily for a specific purpose, directly satisfying the inclusion criteria; I agree with the prior verdict.
Read the full account“I knew that my voice was part of my body and not part of me.”
Context: The experiencer, separated from their body as Spirit, reflects that bodily functions like voice and breath belong to the body, not to the true self.
Review note: The passage explicitly frames the body as an instrument commanded and used by the Spirit ('I decided that I had to force my body to breathe,' 'commanding my body to take a breath,' 'strengthening this command with the will of the Spirit'), with the self (Spirit) as distinct from and operating the body as a vehicle—agreeing with the prior verdict, which correctly identified this vehicle/instrument
Read the full account“I was in space, designing my body of what I wanted it to look like on earth. My body was floating and my hands were out. It looked like designing an avatar for a game.”
Context: The experiencer describes pre-birth consciousness designing the physical body like an avatar, explicitly framing the body as a constructed instrument separate from the designing self.
Review note: The passage clearly supports the claim: the body is explicitly described as something the self designed and chose (like an avatar/game character), with the self existing as a separate 'small orb' — this is stronger than mere mentions and meets the inclusion criteria of body-as-instrument/vehicle framing; I upgrade from the prior 'mentions' verdict because a clear verbatim quote is available that d
Read the full account“I realized the true vastness of my Being and the minuscule nature of the cage of the earthly body.”
Context: Near the end of the passage, after the experiencer has been transformed in the divine light, she reflects on the relationship between her true self and her physical form.
Review note: The passage explicitly frames the earthly body as a 'cage' (instrument/vessel the self is not identical to) and the self as a 'spark of Light' distinct from the body, plus the golden boat transports the body as a vessel—these together clearly affirm the body-as-temporary-vehicle/garment framing, warranting 'supports' rather than the prior 'mentions'; the prior quote was also less precise than the
Read the full account“they fell away like shells from around my consciousness until there was only my awareness”
Context: The experiencer describes earthly concerns, identity, and ego being stripped away as they rose upward, using the 'shells' metaphor explicitly.
Review note: I agree with the prior verdict: the 'shells' metaphor directly frames the body and earthly identity as temporary outer layers surrounding the true self (consciousness/awareness), which aligns with the vehicle/garment framing in the claim definition; the passage also reinforces this with phrases like 'de-shelling of my consciousness' and 'I had no artifice of identity, ego, or any earthly concerns,
Read the full account“they fell away like shells from around my consciousness until there was only my awareness”
Context: The experiencer describes earthly concerns and identity markers being stripped away during ascent, using explicit shell language to describe the body/identity as a temporary covering.
Review note: I agree with the prior verdict: the passage uses explicit 'shell' language ('fell away like shells from around my consciousness') and the experiencer later coins the term 'de-shelling' to describe the process, framing earthly identity and the body as temporary coverings distinct from the core consciousness — directly matching the vehicle/garment claim; however, the framing is slightly more about i
Read the full account“I once again felt the heaviness of my body. In fact, it was more than a month before I felt somewhat comfortable in my body.”
Context: After being revived, the experiencer weeps not at being saved but at returning to the body, describing it as something heavy and uncomfortable that they had to re-acclimate to.
Review note: The passage clearly frames the body as an external, burdensome thing the self inhabits but is not identical to—seen 'just below me' as an object, referenced as 'my body' in third-person observational terms, and experienced as a heavy vessel one must become 'comfortable in' again—satisfying the vehicle/garment framing; I disagree with the prior 'mentions' verdict and upgrade to 'supports' because t
Read the full account“When my soul came out of my body, I felt like a new being, leaving behind all my old senses, thoughts, and emotions.”
Context: This follows the narrator's description of soul-body separation at the point of death, with the soul floating above and observing the broken body below.
Review note: The passage explicitly frames the body as something the soul departs from and leaves behind ('leaving behind all my old senses'), treating the body as an instrument distinct from the self ('I' in dual existence, soul floating above watching 'my body'), which affirms the vehicle/garment framing; I partially disagree with the prior's downgrade to 'mentions' since this is stronger than mere separatio
Read the full account“there is no 'death' only in that the body becomes useless to us and is cast off”
Context: The experiencer reflects post-NDE that the body is something that becomes useless and is discarded, distinct from the self.
Review note: downgraded: quote not verbatim. I agree with the prior verdict: the passage explicitly frames the body as something external to the self that is 'cast off' when it becomes 'useless to us,' and further reinforces this with 'not being encumbered by this body' and the box/package metaphor ('I don't fit back into this box of body and mind'), all of which align with the vehicle/garment framing where bo
Read the full account“I know I didn't want to go back into my body.”
Context: The experiencer, outside their body watching family try to revive them, explicitly describes the body as something separate to return 'back into.'
Review note: downgraded: quote not verbatim. The passage repeatedly frames the body as a separate container the self inhabits ('my earthly body,' 'go back into my body,' 'go back to my body,' 'the real me' existing outside it), which directly affirms the vehicle/vessel framing of the claim; I upgrade from 'mentions' to 'supports' because the language of returning 'back into' the body and references to 'my eart
Read the full account“I was performing some type of spiritual algorithms in regard to the usefulness of the fleshy body as well as the surrounding events below”
Context: The experiencer, floating above the scene, explicitly evaluates the 'fleshy body' as an instrument whose usefulness is being assessed from the perspective of a separate self.
Review note: downgraded: quote not verbatim. The passage repeatedly frames the body as something the soul/self uses, leaves, reconnects with, and ultimately abandons ('the fleshy body,' 'my physical form,' 'I moved further out... disconnecting,' 'I had Chosen to leave my body'), consistent with body-as-vehicle framing; I agree with the prior verdict, and the 'fleshy body usefulness' quote is a particularly str
Read the full account“I felt like my soul was being pulled out of my body”
Context: I was watching TV and out of nowhere I felt like my soul was being pulled out of my body, I actually saw my body on the bed for a split second.
Review note: I agree with the prior verdict: the passage implies a soul/body distinction through separation, which is adjacent to the vehicle/garment framing, but lacks explicit language describing the body as a vessel, tool, or instrument the self uses—making 'mentions' more appropriate than 'supports'.
Read the full account“I remember at one point I viewed my body as "her" ..feeling an attachment but not feeling it to be "me".”
Context: The experiencer describes viewing their physical body as a separate entity ('her') during the OBE, feeling attachment but not identity with it.
Review note: I agree with the prior verdict: the passage clearly expresses non-identity between self and body (viewing body as 'her'), which touches the claim's theme of body-as-instrument, but lacks the explicit vehicle/garment/vessel metaphorical framing required by the claim definition to rise to 'supports'.
Read the full account“a vessel without a soul”
Context: The narrator describes lying unconscious on the bus for over six hours as 'a vessel without a soul,' implying body-soul distinction.
Review note: I agree with the prior verdict: the phrase 'vessel without a soul' invokes body-as-vehicle language and implies the self/soul is separable from the physical body, but it describes an unconscious state rather than developing the body-as-temporary-instrument framing the claim requires, so 'mentions' is appropriate rather than 'supports.'
Read the full account“My body seemed to crush me and it seemed much too small for me.”
Context: The experiencer describes returning to the body after an OBE and feeling constrained by it.
Review note: I disagree with the prior verdict: while the passage conveys that the body feels constraining and too small upon return, this is closer to an OBE separation narrative (excluded) or a body-as-prison framing (also excluded) than the vehicle/garment/instrument framing the claim requires; there is no explicit language of the body as a tool or vessel the self uses, so 'mentions' is more appropriate tha
Read the full account“Even though I was without a physical body, this feeling of nakedness was more than I could bear at that moment”
Context: The experiencer notes being without a physical body during the experience, implying a separation of self from body.
Review note: The passage describes separation from the body ('without a physical body') and returning to it ('fell through the top of my bedroom ceiling, hit my body with a jolt'), which touches on body-self distinction, but never frames the body as a vehicle, garment, or instrument the self uses—the framing is pure-awareness dissolution rather than vehicle/instrument language, so 'mentions' is correct and I a
Read the full account“My identity as a human personality was reborn, but it was now a mental construct, an interface with the world and other people.”
Context: After the ego-death and rebirth experience, the narrator describes how identity and ego returned but in a reduced, instrumental role.
Review note: I agree with the PRIOR verdict of 'mentions': the passage touches on the body/identity as separable from the deeper self (ego as 'tool', identity as 'mental construct', 'interface'), and mentions 'My body is still alive' as distinct from the experiential self, but never employs vehicle/garment/vessel language explicitly framing the body as a temporary instrument the self uses, which is required fo
Read the full account“In some sense, physical existence feels like a steal box. It is one with inextricable walls.”
Context: The narrator opens by describing physical existence as a constricting box with inextricable walls.
Review note: The 'steal box' metaphor frames physical existence as a confining enclosure, which touches the vehicle/vessel language of the claim, but the dominant framing is confinement/imprisonment rather than the body as an instrument the self uses — making 'mentions' more accurate than 'supports'; I disagree with the prior verdict of 'supports' because the passage's emphasis is on the body/physical existenc
Read the full account“I landed on a level, which was narrow, cold, dark; on the level of the physical body. I knew this is the level on which I will exist further on.”
Context: The experiencer describes descending through planes and arriving at the physical body's level, distinct from the luminous realm she identifies as her true home.
Review note: I agree with the prior verdict: the passage implies the self is distinct from and temporarily housed at the level of the physical body, touching the vehicle/garment concept, but it lacks explicit vehicle, garment, or vessel language required for 'supports.'
Read the full account“I had read before about the concept of the astral body and believe this is what I had become.”
Context: The experiencer has just realized he is out of his physical body and is observing it from above.
Review note: The passage describes an OBE with the experiencer observing his physical body as an external object ('my poor body,' 'my cadaver,' 'my physical body'), and references the 'astral body' concept, but the framing is primarily separation/OBE language rather than explicit vehicle/garment/vessel framing where the body is described as an instrument the self uses — the prior verdict overclaims 'supports'
Read the full account“I felt brutally propelled into my body.”
Context: After deciding to return for his mother and brother, the experiencer describes being forcefully returned to the physical body.
Review note: The passage describes clear body-self separation (OBE, floating, being 'propelled into' the body as if returning to a container) which hints at the body-as-vehicle framing, but lacks explicit vehicle/garment/vessel language; the prior verdict of 'mentions' is correct, as the passage goes slightly further than simple OBE with the 'propelled into my body' phrasing suggesting the body is a distinct r
Read the full account“I was without body but more specifically, I was without mass.”
Context: The experiencer describes moving freely through space during an out-of-body-like state, noting the absence of physical constraints.
Review note: I partially disagree with the prior verdict: while the passage does describe separation from the body and consciousness existing independently, the framing is primarily an OBE/separation narrative rather than explicit vehicle/garment/instrument language; the body is not described as a tool the self 'uses' but rather as something left behind, making this more of a simple separation account that tou
Read the full account“The next thing I remember was me, about 10 feet away from my body. I was looking at the body, whose eyes were closed.”
Context: The experiencer describes observing their own body from a distance after falling into the lake.
Review note: The passage depicts a clear separation from the body and refers to it in objectified third-person terms ('the body'), which touches on the vehicle/garment framing but never explicitly articulates the body as a temporary instrument or vessel distinct from identity, so 'mentions' is appropriate and I agree with the prior verdict.
Read the full account“I felt I entered my body like a solid object, with a jerk.”
Context: The experiencer describes re-entering the body after deciding to return from the non-physical state.
Review note: The passage describes classic OBE separation with the self observing the body as an external object, and the re-entry language ('entered my body like a solid object') has mild vehicle/vessel connotations, but the dominant framing is simple OBE separation rather than explicit vehicle/garment/instrument language; the prior verdict overstates the support, as the passage lacks clear 'body as instrumen
Read the full account“I was indifferent toward the "body" lying on the hospital bed, even though I knew that was "me," but it felt like that was someone else. I was detached from her completely, additionally she looked like a wax figure.”
Context: The experiencer observes her physical body from above during an OBE, describing it as a 'wax figure' and feeling completely detached from it.
Review note: The passage clearly distinguishes between the conscious self and the physical body (wax figure, detachment, 'someone else'), and later explicitly frames the soul as separate from the body ('my soul had left my body,' 're-entering into my flesh'), which approaches vehicle/garment framing but stops short of explicit instrument-not-identity language; 'mentions' is appropriate and I agree with the pri
Read the full account“I didn't had my human body.”
Context: The experiencer describes having no human body during the experience, implying separation from it.
Review note: I agree with the prior verdict: the passage notes absence of the human body and adopts a non-bodily ellipsoid form, touching on body-as-non-identity, but never uses vehicle/garment/vessel framing nor explicitly describes the body as a temporary instrument the self uses, so 'mentions' is more appropriate than 'supports'.
Read the full account“I was being put into another body right after that death”
Context: After experiencing a past-life death, the experiencer describes being moved into successive bodies across lifetimes, implying the body is a temporary vessel for the soul.
Review note: I disagree with the prior verdict of 'irrelevant' because the passage does touch on vehicle-like framing through the reincarnation sequence—being 'sucked into another body' and 'being put into another body' implies the self is distinct from and moves through bodies—but the framing is implicit rather than explicit instrument/vehicle language, so 'mentions' rather than 'supports' is appropriate.
Read the full accountReview note: I agree with the prior verdict: the passage describes complete dissolution of identity and body with no framing of the body as a vehicle or instrument the self uses — there is simply no self or body present, which is incompatible with the vehicle/garment framing required by the claim.
Read the full account